CVE-2023-44378
gnark unsoundness in variable comparison / non-unique binary decomposition
Impact
### Impact For some in-circuit values, it is possible to construct two valid decomposition to bits. In addition to the canonical decomposition of `a`, for small values there exists a second decomposition for `a+r` (where `r` is the modulus the values are being reduced by). The second decomposition was possible due to overflowing the field where the values are defined. Internally, the comparison methods `frontend.API.Cmp` and `frontend.API.IsLess` used binary decomposition and checked the bitwise differences. This allows a malicious prover to construct a valid proof for a statement `a < b` even if `a > b`. The issue impacts all users using `API.Cmp` or `API.IsLess` methods. Additionally, it impacts the users using `bits.ToBinary` or `API.ToBinary` methods if full-width decomposition is requested (the default behaviour if no options are given). The issues does not impact comparison methods in field emulation (package `std/math/emulated`) and dedicated comparison package (`std/math/cmp`). ### Patches Fix has been implemented in pull request #835 and merged in commit 59a4087261a6c73f13e80d695c17b398c3d0934f to master branch. The release v0.9.0 and onwards include the fix. The fix added additional comparison of the decomposed bit-vector to the modulus of the in-circuit values. ### Workarounds Upgrading to version v0.9.0 should fix the issue without needing to change the calls to value comparison methods. Alternatively, users can use the `std/math/cmp` gadget, which additionally allows to bound the number of bits being compared, making the comparisons more efficient if the bound on the absolute difference of the values is known. ### References * https://github.com/Consensys/gnark/pull/835 * https://github.com/zkopru-network/zkopru/issues/116 * https://github.com/iden3/circomlib/pull/48 ### Acknowledgement The vulnerability was reported by [Marcin Kostrzewa](https://github.com/kustosz) @ [Reilabs](https://reilabs.io/).
Affected packages
| Ecosystem | Package | Affected | Fixed in |
|---|---|---|---|
| go | github.com/consensys/gnark | < 0.9.0 | 0.9.0 |
Affected products
| Vendor | Product | Affected versions |
|---|---|---|
| Consensys | Gnark | before 0.9.0 |
Weakness classification
References
- NVD record
- CVE.org record
- GitHub advisory
- https://github.com/Consensys/gnark/commit/59a4087261a6c73f13e80d695c17b398c3d0934f
- https://github.com/Consensys/gnark/security/advisories/GHSA-498w-5j49-vqjg
- https://github.com/zkopru-network/zkopru/issues/116
- https://github.com/advisories/GHSA-498w-5j49-vqjg
- https://github.com/Consensys/gnark/pull/835
- https://nvd.nist.gov/vuln/detail/CVE-2023-44378